Crypto & Fintech

What Happens When a Stablecoin Loses Its Peg? Runs, Reserves and Redemption

A stablecoin is meant to trade at one dollar, but it can slip below that. Here is how a depeg happens, what central banks and the Federal Reserve found, and why full reserves do not guarantee calm.

Blue circuit board

A stablecoin loses its peg when its market price drifts away from the one dollar (or other currency) it is meant to track, usually because holders doubt they can swap it back at full value. This article explains how that happens, why it can spread, and what recent research from central banks says about it.

What does it mean for a stablecoin to lose its peg?

A stablecoin is a digital token designed to keep a steady value, typically one US dollar. The “peg” is that one-for-one target. Our earlier explainer on what backs stablecoins and what can go wrong covers the basic designs. This piece looks at the moment the promise is tested.

A depeg is a gap between the price people actually pay and the stated value. The gap can be small and brief, a few cents for a few hours, or it can be severe and lasting. The reason is rarely a flaw in the software. It is almost always a question of confidence: do holders believe the token can be turned back into a dollar at par, meaning at full face value, when they ask?

Two prices: the issuer’s promise and the market’s quote

A Federal Reserve staff note on stablecoin markets, published in February 2024, separates two arenas. In the primary market, tokens are created (minted) and destroyed (burned) directly with the issuer. In the secondary market, holders trade with one another on exchanges.

The note explains that fiat-backed issuers usually limit minting and burning to approved institutional customers. It names USD Coin (USDC) as open mainly to businesses such as exchanges, fintech firms and institutional traders that pass an application process, and describes Tether (USDT) as available to approved customers, usually companies. Ordinary retail holders therefore generally rely on the secondary market.

That split explains how a depeg can occur even when the issuer has not changed its terms. If many holders sell at once, the exchange price can fall below one dollar while the issuer’s official redemption rate stays at one dollar.

How arbitrage normally holds the peg

The Fed note describes the everyday repair mechanism, called arbitrage, meaning profiting from a price gap. A direct customer can buy a token at, say, 98 cents on an exchange and redeem it with the issuer for a dollar. If the token trades above a dollar, the same customer can mint new tokens and sell them. These trades push the market price back toward the peg.

The mechanism depends on two things: the issuer being willing and able to redeem, and the arbitrageur trusting that it will. The authors note that access to the primary market matters for how well arbitrage works. If either condition fails, the price can stay below par.

What is a stablecoin run?

A run is what happens when many holders try to exit simultaneously. The European Central Bank, in a November 2025 Financial Stability Review box, identifies the core vulnerability as investors losing confidence in redemption at par, and says that loss of confidence can trigger a run and a de-pegging at the same time.

The mechanics resemble a bank run. A fully backed issuer may still hold reserves that cannot be sold instantly, or that sit in a place the issuer cannot reach. The first holders to leave get paid in full, so each holder has a reason to leave early. That self-reinforcing logic is why confidence matters more than the headline reserve figure.

Worked example: when reserves are full but not all reachable

The following illustrative arithmetic is not drawn from any real issuer. Suppose a stablecoin has 1,000,000 tokens outstanding and exactly $1,000,000 in reserves. Of that, 8 percent ($80,000) is held at a bank that suddenly fails and freezes deposits. The remaining $920,000 is liquid.

  • If holders redeem 920,000 tokens, the issuer can pay all of them at par.
  • The last 80,000 tokens are backed by money that is temporarily out of reach.
  • A holder who cannot tell which tokens will be paid may sell at a discount instead of waiting, which pushes the market price down for everyone.

The reserves are technically complete, yet the token trades below par because timing and access are uncertain.

What happened in March 2023?

The best-documented case is USDC in March 2023. According to a Federal Reserve note published in December 2025, Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) entered resolution on the morning of March 10, 2023, after more than $40 billion in single-day withdrawals. Circle, USDC’s issuer, said it could not withdraw $3.3 billion of reserves held at SVB. The note puts that at about 8 percent of Circle’s total reserves, which it describes as over $40 billion. That share matches the proportion used in the worked example above.

The Fed authors report that USDC traded as low as 86 cents at its trough, though hourly charts show a low nearer 90 cents. The price recovered after the Treasury, the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation announced on Sunday, March 12, that SVB depositors would be protected. It recovered fully once Circle resumed processing redemptions on Monday, March 13. The note adds that between that Monday morning and March 15, Circle redeemed $3.8 billion of USDC and issued $0.8 billion.

How did the stress spread to other stablecoins?

The 2023 episode did not stay inside USDC. The Fed note reports that Dai, which had no direct exposure to SVB, lost its peg through a smart-contract facility that let users swap USDC for Dai, the Peg Stability Module. That facility reached its daily cap of 950 million USDC. Pax Dollar (USDP) fell to a low of about 91 cents after more than 400 million of it was withdrawn from its own module, more than half its supply. Gemini Dollar (GUSD) fell to about 96 cents.

Money also moved toward perceived safety. The Fed note says USDT and Binance USD rose slightly above $1 during the stress. A separate Fed note counts a month-long shift: between March 1 and April 1, USDC’s market capitalization fell about $9.7 billion while USDT’s rose about $8.8 billion.

Trading infrastructure added friction. The February 2024 Fed note says exchanges that had offered one-for-one USDC trades paused them during the episode, cutting off exits for sellers.

Why are full reserves not a guarantee?

Researchers at the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) examined this tension in Working Paper 1164, published in January 2024. They model how the quality of an issuer’s reserve assets affects the coordination among holders. They find that when reserve volatility is unknown, a peg can survive small shocks but fail after a large negative public shock to reserve values, even if reserves started high.

The BIS authors also find that public disclosure cuts both ways. Publishing reserve details raises run risk when holders’ prior beliefs about reserve quality are low, and lowers it when those beliefs are high. They conclude there is a trade-off between peg stability and issuer fragility.

The Federal Reserve authors reach a related view about 2023. They conclude that stablecoins with high-quality reserves can still be fragile under stress, and that stress can pass in both directions between banks and stablecoins. Without the public backstop, they say, pressure on USDC could have forced sales of Treasury securities.

Could a depeg reach beyond crypto?

The ECB’s assessment is measured. It judges the risks to the euro area as currently limited, while arguing that rapid growth justifies close monitoring. Its box gives the following picture as of November 2025:

Measure ECB figure
Combined stablecoin market value Above $280 billion, about 8% of the crypto-asset market
Share held by USDT and USDC About 63% and 26%
US dollar-denominated share of supply Around 99%
Euro-denominated stablecoins About €395 million
Share of crypto-platform trades involving stablecoins About 80%

The ECB notes that the two largest issuers are among the biggest holders of US Treasury bills, and that a run could force a fire sale, meaning rapid selling at depressed prices, of reserve assets that could affect the functioning of US Treasury markets. It also warns that two issuers account for around 90 percent of circulating stablecoins, so one failure could have wide effects.

On the European side, the ECB says the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCAR) requires issuers to hold at least 30 percent of reserves as bank deposits and bans interest on stablecoin holdings. It also flags the risk of regulatory arbitrage across countries, for example if multi-country issuance leaves EU issuers with too few reserves to meet combined redemption requests. How the newer US federal rules interact with this is covered in our earlier piece, and the broader question of public digital money is explored in our guide to the digital euro.

Common misconceptions

  • “Stable” means guaranteed. The name describes a goal. Most stablecoins are not covered by deposit insurance, and a price below par is a market outcome, not a broken contract.
  • A depeg means the issuer is insolvent. In March 2023 the price fell because reserves were temporarily out of reach and confidence dropped, and it recovered once redemptions resumed.
  • Every holder can redeem at par. The Fed note shows direct redemption is often limited to approved institutional customers.
  • Only the troubled token is affected. Dai had no direct SVB exposure and still lost its peg through a linked mechanism.

What the evidence leaves open

The research agrees on the mechanism but not on the remedy. Disclosure can calm or inflame depending on what holders already believe. Faster redemption can reduce discounts but can also speed a run. Stablecoins are also tied to ordinary payment rails, as our explainer on instant bank payments shows, so weakness at a partner bank can matter as much as weakness in the token.

The Federal Reserve authors say missing guardrails and backstops likely increase the probability and severity of stress, and call for further research. The remaining unknown is how a much larger market would behave under the same pressure, a question the ECB raises when it notes some projections of far greater growth by 2028.

What a depeg teaches about confidence

A stablecoin loses its peg when confidence in par redemption falters, and the cause can sit outside the token itself: a failed bank, a frozen facility or a paused exchange. Reserves, redemption access and disclosure all shape the outcome, and the 2023 episode showed that even well-backed tokens can wobble when those links strain.

This article is general information, not financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

Sources: Federal Reserve Board; European Central Bank; Bank for International Settlements